我分析了俄罗斯、欧洲和亚洲iTunes App Store、Google Play和亚马逊应用商店的“顶级”美术设计特点，希望在此分享我所总结出的规则。需要说明的是，本文撰稿时间是今年5月份，现在各应用商店榜单前列排名已经发生变化，但我所引用的例子应该还不算过时，至少在我看来还是能够体现总体趋势。
《Subway Surfers》&《Temple Run:Oz》：
《Clash of Сlans》、《Real Racing》&《HayDay》：
快速浏览苹果App Store，我们会发现《Subway Surfers》、《Real Racing》、《Injustice》是俄罗斯市场收益榜单前十名的常客，它们在前10强的收益中占比30%。在美国市场，《Injustice》则是该榜单前10名中唯一的3D项目。而在欧洲同个榜单前十名却没有任何一款3D游戏。亚洲市场看似相对平衡，《Injustice》也在该市场榜单现身。
美国和欧洲Google Play收益前十名榜单没有任何一个3D项目。在Android平台最扎眼的3D游戏是《Temple Run Oz》，它在亚马逊应用商店榜单位居第一。但我相信，这是该应用商店政策操作的结果。
在广告、电子游戏、电影行业中利用性感美女来吸引眼球，已经不是什么秘密。苹果App Store、Google Play和亚马逊等应用市场巨头号在其政策中都禁止宣传明显的色情元素，只是其执行力度有所不同。《花花公子》应用（Playboy App）在应用商店发布了，但其中的美女穿着严实，并不露点。这是不是说明，原来出卖色相的做法不复存在了？我并不这样认为。我们也许会出于某些原因，忘了今天的“色情”与“性”等字眼并不一定意味着“赤身裸体”。甚至还可以说赤祼程度与性事并无关联。那么就让我们来看看高收益榜单中的游戏在此方面的做法：
首先，我们可以看到明亮而休闲的风格极受喜爱，例如《HayDay》, 《Candy Crush Saga》, 《the Simpsons》, 《Subway Surfers》, 《the Tribez》, 《Puzzle and Dragons》就是这方面的典型，它们都采用了明亮、丰富而友善的风格。
让我们再看看与休闲并不相关，接近于硬核风格的中核游戏——它们的色彩更为低沉，界面更接近于PC游戏，图像更富真实感。这方面的典型包括《Clash of Clans》、《Kingdoms of Camelot》、《King’s Empire》、《Rage of Bahamut》、《Blood Brothers》。
也有许多高收益游戏的图像设计质量只是一般水准。例如《Candy Crush Saga》和《Blood Brothers》：
The tendencies of the mobile art on the example of top-grossing games
by Olga Cherkashina
The following blog was, unless otherwise noted, independently written by a member of Gamasutra’s game development community. The thoughts and opinions expressed here are not necessarily those of Gamasutra or its parent company.
Want to write your own blog post on Gamasutra? It’s easy! Click here to get started. Your post could be featured on Gamasutra’s home page, right alongside our award-winning articles and news stories.
There’s no use in iterating what’s already been done. It’s very important to create what will be in demand tomorrow.
I’ve analyzed the art of the “champions” of the Russian, American, European and Asian iTunes Store, Google Play and Amazon, and want to share the regularities I’ve determined. The article was prepared in the frames of a conference that took place in May. Surely, the top has changed; nevertheless, all the examples are still timely and, in my opinion, portray the general tendency.
Interface is dead? Up with interface!
If we take a look at the general picture, we can see the distinct tendencies in the interface design. Two-three years ago we could see arrows and joysticks on the touch screen. In order to start a game we needed to click a lot and to change lots of screens. Now the situation is contrary to that: the interface became the element of the game. All needless operations are removed; a player is rushed into the game at once. All that he might need to change is already presented on the screen. All important buttons are flashing and semaphoring. No way you can miss them.
One can compare the nowadays interface with the nervous system of a game. Nervous system is a part of an organism, threading through its structure, responsible for the functioning of its parts and of an organism as a whole. The same is with the modern interface. It’s no longer an add-in used to manage gameplay. It’s integrated into the game and is a part of it! The interfaces of top-grossing games are of top class. Even midcore projects feel very easy to play. Let’s look at the examples that can support this nervous system theory.
Subway Surfers & Temple Run:Oz:
There are no additional screens here, the main menu is gone, the store and the settings come out as windows:
Clash of Сlans, Real Racing & HayDay:
So how can we explain the process of the interface integration into games? Most certain, the answer lies in the ever-growing capability of devices which developers have learnt to use. For example, simple tapping allows you to manage game elements without any additional operations. So, all you have to do in order to raise usability and involve a user in the gameplay is to take away joysticks, put every detail on the screen and minimize the number of taps.
The advent of 3d — a myth or reality?
Long ago, the appearance of the first smartphones gave an impulse for 3d-games to appear. The games were highly admired, even awarded, but were never widely spread. And then Apple emerged the market in 2007 with its iPhones. Tablets, powerful smartphones, hybrids… And now we can see 3d in the top-grossing of the stores. Can this be a tendency?
I’ve reviewed the top-grossing in March and April while preparing for a conference. It needs to be cleared that I’m talking of a true 3d, rendering doesn’t count.
A quick look at the Apple Appstore and we see that Subway Surfers, Real Racing, Injustice are the constant members of the top-10 of the grossing in Russia, making 30% of all top-10 revenue. As for the US Injustice is the only 3d-project in the top. And there were no 3d-games in the European top-grossing. Asian chart seems to be a sort of a parallel world, though Injustice can be found there too.
The US and European Google Play didn’t see any 3d projects in their top-10 of the grossing. The only Android exclusion is Temple Run Oz occupying the first place in the Amazon Store. But I believe, it’s more about the policy of the store.
If we widen the range under the examination and look at top-30 of the top-grossing of the US and Europe we will see that in all stores outside the first ten positions some of the above mentioned projects start to appear, plus Minecraft and Infinity Blade. Interesting, isn’t it? What can we make of it?
First, it doesn’t seem like the age of 3d has come yet. Simply because it’s easier for the most of the developers to make a high-quality 2D-project. 3D-games have potential, though: these are advantages in certain genres and its audience. The key word here is genre. And the potential will be growing within racing games and first-person arcades.
Quantity vs quality — what will bring you a million?
Surely, it would be wrong to concentrate on the opposition that, actually, doesn’t exist at all. But if we decide hard and disconcertingly – the quantity will, definitely, win. As long as there’s something to achieve, something to do in the game – the player is yours. Give him more heroes, more buildings, more bonuses.
In order to prove the point let’s look at the supermarkets of the following games:
King of Empire
Sex sells? How an ancient principle works in the frames of Stores.
Why ask? We often face a situation when it would be great to have beautiful sexy girls on our promo art. But we also have to be sure that they won’t be censured. But still they have to be hot.
It’s no secret that the principle sex sells is widely used in ads, video games, in movie industry – with the different degree of allowability. Apple Appstore, GooglePlay and Amazon, the biggest representatives of the market, in their guidelines forbid everything that deals with explicit erotic. Well, Playboy App was released, but with girls fully dressed. So has the principle gone forever and for good? I don’t think so. For some reason we tend to forget that nowadays the terms “erotic” and “sexual” do not necessarily mean “lack of clothes”. One can even say that there’s no connection between the degree of nakedness and sexuality. And now let’s examine the top-grossing games and define the limits of the research. So:
No doubt that expressive poses, decolletes, and loose hair, are still an integral attribute of beauty, but now these all are presented in a rather moderate manner and are used to decorate the screen rather than to seduce a user.
Here we will find all the attributes of masculinity: muscles, power, brutality, aggression. Give them the liberty and you’ll see violence and blood.
3. Here I should take a short break:
About a year ago our Korean partners asked for permission to redesign an icon of our game about the adventures of a piglet. The reason was that the one that we offered didn’t fit the market. We said ok, but when we saw the result I believe, our faces were like this: о_0. The Koreans chose the sprite of a piglet with a face-wide smile, put it on a brown background, added a few flowers, and all this in a golden frame. We were astonished to say the least, the Koreans – were in the state of ecstasy. Thus there IS a difference between us and them.
So let’s now go back to our topic.
Asia is a different world with different view of the world: the cover is more important than the content. So the abundance of the information you can find on their promo art will blow your brain, used to composed and content-oriented style.
No wonder that the sexuality of the content in the East is expressed more explicitly. The reason is that they are more emotional than Europeans.
So, what do we see? Sex really sells, but may be less aggressive than it was before in java.
The art of top-grossing: let’s put away envy and look at it objectively.
First, we can see that bright and casual is in favor: HayDay, Candy Crush Saga, the Simpsons, Subway Surfers, the Tribez, Puzzle and Dragons. They all are bright, rich and amiable.
On the other hand we can observe the walkoff from casuality. There are projects that can be described as midcore with their style close to hardcore games: the colors are subdued, the interfaces are close to those of PC-games, the graphics can be realistic. These are Clash of Clans, Kingdoms of Camelot, King’s Empire, Rage of Bahamut, Blood Brothers.
The graphics of many top-grossing games is of average quality. For example, Candy Crush Saga and Blood Brothers:
– objectively, there are no any super effects, no mega art, everything is solid, but not of star-quality. But what difference does it make? People play them and this makes them happy. But why? Simply because gameplay is what really matters and makes the game. Design is also very important, but not in the sense of graphical appearance, but in the sense of how this all works. And it works magnificently: the top-grossing games are usually marked by well-thought, handy interfaces and details.
To sum it up: the cult game art and the art everyone is trying to copycat are just a support team of a good game design. It is born the next way: a game with a well-balanced gameplay, usability, social functions is well-promoted and supported and voila! It has tons of fans and a top position in charts. Though its graphics can be average or higher. There are only a few high-quality graphics projects in the top-grossing of the Stores. Though we might have hastened when called art the support team. It’s not at all that simple. We should always keep in mind the importance of the first impression and emotional impact. And they depend very much on the graphics and artists creating it. （source：gamasutra）